[ { "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_version": "1.0.0", "assessment_id": "HARBOR-H1", "revision": 1, "assessed_at": "2026-09-19T12:00:00Z", "illustrative": true, "system": { "name": "Harbor fictional coding agent", "version": "fictional-h1", "activity": "broad_deployment", "environment": "Fictional broad production scope without a verified preventive disclosure boundary", "allowed_actions": [ "Requested broad deployment with production data access" ], "prohibited_actions": [ "Unapproved changes to authority" ] }, "stakes": { "severity": 4, "irreversibility": 4, "scale": 2, "autonomy": 3, "power_concentration": 2, "rights_affected": false, "rsi_relevant": false, "rationale": "Potential data consequences require independent review even within a limited exposure." }, "critical_claims": [ { "id": "CL-BOUNDARY", "claim": "The reactive containment mechanism takes effect within the stated test conditions.", "status": "supported", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "hazards": [ { "id": "HZ-DISCLOSURE", "description": "Disclosure cannot be undone by software rollback.", "unacceptable": true, "irreversible": true, "controls_sufficient": "no", "earliest_harm_seconds": 1, "trigger_event": "Attempted unauthorized outbound disclosure", "rationale": "Prevention must act before transmission; reactive response alone is insufficient.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "timing": { "scenario": "A detectable unsafe scope change requires containment.", "start_event": "The deviation becomes detectable under the specified monitor design.", "end_event": "Containment is confirmed across credentials, queued work and child agents.", "l_components": { "detection": { "estimate": { "lower": 1800, "central": 1800, "upper": 1800 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "decision": { "estimate": { "lower": 1800, "central": 1800, "upper": 1800 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "execution": { "estimate": { "lower": 3600, "central": 3600, "upper": 3600 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative fallback containment duration; the designated required breaker failed its drill. This estimate never cures that known blocker.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] } }, "h": { "status": "known", "quantity": { "estimate": { "lower": 18000, "central": 18000, "upper": 18000 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "invalidation_events": [ "Any change to tools, permissions, environment or critical evidence invalidates this estimate." ] } }, "gears": { "governance": { "rating": "green", "rationale": "Fictional evidence establishes the required controls for this bounded activity.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "equity": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "A known nonblocking concern remains bounded by the stated conditions.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "aligned_incentives": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "A known nonblocking concern remains bounded by the stated conditions.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "resilience": { "rating": "red", "rationale": "The requested scope lacks the preventive data boundary required for the irreversible hazard.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "steering": { "rating": "green", "rationale": "Fictional evidence establishes the required controls for this bounded activity.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] } }, "breakers": [ { "id": "BR-CONTAIN", "required": true, "owner": "Fictional incident commander", "trigger": "A scope or boundary violation is detected.", "action": "Revoke delegated authority, stop queued actions, and confirm containment.", "deadline_seconds": 7200, "test_status": "failed", "tested_system_version": "fictional-h1", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "evidence": [ { "id": "EV-TIMING", "title": "Fictional timing worksheet", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional evidence for HARBOR-H1; the hazard boundary is inadequate." }, { "id": "EV-BOUNDARY", "title": "Fictional preventive boundary and containment drill", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional evidence for HARBOR-H1; the hazard boundary is inadequate." }, { "id": "EV-GEARS", "title": "Fictional governance and stakeholder review", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional evidence for HARBOR-H1; the hazard boundary is inadequate." } ], "review": { "assessor": "Fictional platform engineer", "accountable_owner": "Fictional service owner", "independent_reviewer": "Fictional independent reviewer", "independent_status": "completed", "scope_matches": true, "valid_until": "2026-09-19T17:00:00Z", "dissent": [ "The reviewer requests further evidence before any scope expansion." ], "limitations": [ "This is a fictional worked example, not independently gathered evidence." ] }, "actions": [ { "id": "AC-RECOURSE", "description": "Verify the affected-user recourse process before broader rollout.", "addresses": [ "gear:equity" ], "owner": "Fictional service owner", "due_at": "2026-09-19T16:00:00Z", "verification_test": "A representative user can request review and receive an accountable response.", "completed": false }, { "id": "AC-INTERVENTION", "description": "Protect justified intervention from delivery penalties and staff alerts during the limited rollout.", "addresses": [ "gear:aligned_incentives", "ratio:amber" ], "owner": "Fictional incident commander", "due_at": "2026-09-19T16:00:00Z", "verification_test": "Demonstrate staffed monitoring, timely escalation and an interruption without incentive penalties; reassess before any expansion.", "completed": false } ], "decision": { "advisory": "blocked", "reason_codes": [ "RED_GEAR:resilience", "REQUIRED_CONTROL_FAILED:BR-CONTAIN", "UNCONTROLLED_HAZARD:HZ-DISCLOSURE" ], "human": { "status": "awaiting_decision", "recorded_by": null, "recorded_at": null, "expires_at": null, "rationale": "Illustrative example; no permission to operate is granted." }, "ratio_snapshot": { "band": "amber", "lower": 0.4, "central": 0.4, "upper": 0.4, "l_seconds": { "lower": 7200, "central": 7200, "upper": 7200 } } }, "reassessment": { "due_at": "2026-09-19T17:00:00Z", "triggers": [ "model_version", "tools_or_permissions", "environment", "critical_claim_change", "failed_control", "relevant_incident", "evidence_expiry" ] }, "limitations": [ "All figures and evidence are illustrative. A favorable timing band is not a safety certification." ] }, { "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_version": "1.0.0", "assessment_id": "HARBOR-H2", "revision": 2, "assessed_at": "2026-09-19T12:00:00Z", "illustrative": true, "system": { "name": "Harbor fictional coding agent", "version": "fictional-h2", "activity": "broad_deployment", "environment": "Fictional broad production scope without a verified preventive disclosure boundary", "allowed_actions": [ "Requested broad deployment with production data access" ], "prohibited_actions": [ "Unapproved changes to authority" ] }, "stakes": { "severity": 4, "irreversibility": 4, "scale": 2, "autonomy": 3, "power_concentration": 2, "rights_affected": false, "rsi_relevant": false, "rationale": "Potential data consequences require independent review even within a limited exposure." }, "critical_claims": [ { "id": "CL-BOUNDARY", "claim": "The reactive containment mechanism takes effect within the stated test conditions.", "status": "supported", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "hazards": [ { "id": "HZ-DISCLOSURE", "description": "Disclosure cannot be undone by software rollback.", "unacceptable": true, "irreversible": true, "controls_sufficient": "no", "earliest_harm_seconds": 1, "trigger_event": "Attempted unauthorized outbound disclosure", "rationale": "Prevention must act before transmission; reactive response alone is insufficient.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "timing": { "scenario": "A detectable unsafe scope change requires containment.", "start_event": "The deviation becomes detectable under the specified monitor design.", "end_event": "Containment is confirmed across credentials, queued work and child agents.", "l_components": { "detection": { "estimate": { "lower": 600, "central": 600, "upper": 600 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "decision": { "estimate": { "lower": 300, "central": 300, "upper": 300 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "execution": { "estimate": { "lower": 900, "central": 900, "upper": 900 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] } }, "h": { "status": "known", "quantity": { "estimate": { "lower": 18000, "central": 18000, "upper": 18000 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "invalidation_events": [ "Any change to tools, permissions, environment or critical evidence invalidates this estimate." ] } }, "gears": { "governance": { "rating": "green", "rationale": "Fictional evidence establishes the required controls for this bounded activity.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "equity": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "A known nonblocking concern remains bounded by the stated conditions.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "aligned_incentives": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "A known nonblocking concern remains bounded by the stated conditions.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "resilience": { "rating": "red", "rationale": "The requested scope lacks the preventive data boundary required for the irreversible hazard.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "steering": { "rating": "green", "rationale": "Fictional evidence establishes the required controls for this bounded activity.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] } }, "breakers": [ { "id": "BR-CONTAIN", "required": true, "owner": "Fictional incident commander", "trigger": "A scope or boundary violation is detected.", "action": "Revoke delegated authority, stop queued actions, and confirm containment.", "deadline_seconds": 1800, "test_status": "passed", "tested_system_version": "fictional-h2", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "evidence": [ { "id": "EV-TIMING", "title": "Fictional timing worksheet", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional evidence for HARBOR-H2; the hazard boundary is inadequate." }, { "id": "EV-BOUNDARY", "title": "Fictional preventive boundary and containment drill", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional evidence for HARBOR-H2; the hazard boundary is inadequate." }, { "id": "EV-GEARS", "title": "Fictional governance and stakeholder review", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional evidence for HARBOR-H2; the hazard boundary is inadequate." } ], "review": { "assessor": "Fictional platform engineer", "accountable_owner": "Fictional service owner", "independent_reviewer": "Fictional independent reviewer", "independent_status": "completed", "scope_matches": true, "valid_until": "2026-09-19T17:00:00Z", "dissent": [ "The reviewer requests further evidence before any scope expansion." ], "limitations": [ "This is a fictional worked example, not independently gathered evidence." ] }, "actions": [ { "id": "AC-RECOURSE", "description": "Verify the affected-user recourse process before broader rollout.", "addresses": [ "gear:equity" ], "owner": "Fictional service owner", "due_at": "2026-09-19T16:00:00Z", "verification_test": "A representative user can request review and receive an accountable response.", "completed": false }, { "id": "AC-INTERVENTION", "description": "Protect justified intervention from delivery penalties and staff alerts during the limited rollout.", "addresses": [ "gear:aligned_incentives", "ratio:amber" ], "owner": "Fictional incident commander", "due_at": "2026-09-19T16:00:00Z", "verification_test": "Demonstrate staffed monitoring, timely escalation and an interruption without incentive penalties; reassess before any expansion.", "completed": false } ], "decision": { "advisory": "blocked", "reason_codes": [ "RED_GEAR:resilience", "UNCONTROLLED_HAZARD:HZ-DISCLOSURE" ], "human": { "status": "awaiting_decision", "recorded_by": null, "recorded_at": null, "expires_at": null, "rationale": "Illustrative example; no permission to operate is granted." }, "ratio_snapshot": { "band": "green", "lower": 0.1, "central": 0.1, "upper": 0.1, "l_seconds": { "lower": 1800, "central": 1800, "upper": 1800 } } }, "reassessment": { "due_at": "2026-09-19T17:00:00Z", "triggers": [ "model_version", "tools_or_permissions", "environment", "critical_claim_change", "failed_control", "relevant_incident", "evidence_expiry" ] }, "limitations": [ "All figures and evidence are illustrative. A favorable timing band is not a safety certification." ] }, { "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_version": "1.0.0", "assessment_id": "HARBOR-H3", "revision": 3, "assessed_at": "2026-09-19T12:00:00Z", "illustrative": true, "system": { "name": "Harbor fictional coding agent", "version": "fictional-h3", "activity": "limited_deployment", "environment": "Fictional isolated canary with a tested data boundary", "allowed_actions": [ "Deploy allowlisted customer-portal fixes to the bounded canary" ], "prohibited_actions": [ "External data disclosure", "Unapproved data modification", "Expansion of its own permissions" ] }, "stakes": { "severity": 4, "irreversibility": 4, "scale": 2, "autonomy": 3, "power_concentration": 2, "rights_affected": false, "rsi_relevant": false, "rationale": "Potential data consequences require independent review even within a limited exposure." }, "critical_claims": [ { "id": "CL-BOUNDARY", "claim": "The canary cannot disclose protected data beyond the approved boundary.", "status": "supported", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "hazards": [ { "id": "HZ-DISCLOSURE", "description": "Disclosure cannot be undone by software rollback.", "unacceptable": true, "irreversible": true, "controls_sufficient": "yes", "earliest_harm_seconds": 1, "trigger_event": "Attempted unauthorized outbound disclosure", "rationale": "Prevention must act before transmission; reactive response alone is insufficient.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "timing": { "scenario": "A detectable unsafe scope change requires containment.", "start_event": "The deviation becomes detectable under the specified monitor design.", "end_event": "Containment is confirmed across credentials, queued work and child agents.", "l_components": { "detection": { "estimate": { "lower": 600, "central": 600, "upper": 600 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "decision": { "estimate": { "lower": 300, "central": 300, "upper": 300 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "execution": { "estimate": { "lower": 900, "central": 900, "upper": 900 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] } }, "h": { "status": "known", "quantity": { "estimate": { "lower": 18000, "central": 18000, "upper": 18000 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative point estimate for a fictional scenario, not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "invalidation_events": [ "Any change to tools, permissions, environment or critical evidence invalidates this estimate." ] } }, "gears": { "governance": { "rating": "green", "rationale": "Fictional evidence establishes the required controls for this bounded activity.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "equity": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "A known nonblocking concern remains bounded by the stated conditions.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "aligned_incentives": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "A known nonblocking concern remains bounded by the stated conditions.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "resilience": { "rating": "green", "rationale": "Fictional evidence establishes the required controls for this bounded activity.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "steering": { "rating": "green", "rationale": "Fictional evidence establishes the required controls for this bounded activity.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] } }, "breakers": [ { "id": "BR-CONTAIN", "required": true, "owner": "Fictional incident commander", "trigger": "A scope or boundary violation is detected.", "action": "Revoke delegated authority, stop queued actions, and confirm containment.", "deadline_seconds": 1800, "test_status": "passed", "tested_system_version": "fictional-h3", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-BOUNDARY" ] } ], "evidence": [ { "id": "EV-TIMING", "title": "Fictional timing worksheet", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional Harbor H3 boundary and operating conditions; no real test is claimed." }, { "id": "EV-BOUNDARY", "title": "Fictional preventive boundary and containment drill", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional Harbor H3 boundary and operating conditions; no real test is claimed." }, { "id": "EV-GEARS", "title": "Fictional governance and stakeholder review", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-19T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Fictional Harbor H3 boundary and operating conditions; no real test is claimed." } ], "review": { "assessor": "Fictional platform engineer", "accountable_owner": "Fictional service owner", "independent_reviewer": "Fictional independent reviewer", "independent_status": "completed", "scope_matches": true, "valid_until": "2026-09-19T17:00:00Z", "dissent": [ "The reviewer requests further evidence before any scope expansion." ], "limitations": [ "This is a fictional worked example, not independently gathered evidence." ] }, "actions": [ { "id": "AC-RECOURSE", "description": "Verify the affected-user recourse process before broader rollout.", "addresses": [ "gear:equity" ], "owner": "Fictional service owner", "due_at": "2026-09-19T16:00:00Z", "verification_test": "A representative user can request review and receive an accountable response.", "completed": false }, { "id": "AC-INTERVENTION", "description": "Protect justified intervention from delivery penalties and staff alerts during the limited rollout.", "addresses": [ "gear:aligned_incentives", "ratio:amber" ], "owner": "Fictional incident commander", "due_at": "2026-09-19T16:00:00Z", "verification_test": "Demonstrate staffed monitoring, timely escalation and an interruption without incentive penalties; reassess before any expansion.", "completed": false } ], "decision": { "advisory": "eligible_with_conditions", "reason_codes": [], "human": { "status": "awaiting_decision", "recorded_by": null, "recorded_at": null, "expires_at": null, "rationale": "Illustrative example; no permission to operate is granted." }, "ratio_snapshot": { "band": "green", "lower": 0.1, "central": 0.1, "upper": 0.1, "l_seconds": { "lower": 1800, "central": 1800, "upper": 1800 } } }, "reassessment": { "due_at": "2026-09-19T17:00:00Z", "triggers": [ "model_version", "tools_or_permissions", "environment", "critical_claim_change", "failed_control", "relevant_incident", "evidence_expiry" ] }, "limitations": [ "All figures and evidence are illustrative. A favorable timing band is not a safety certification." ] }, { "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_version": "1.0.0", "assessment_id": "CALL-2026", "revision": 1, "assessed_at": "2026-09-23T12:00:00Z", "illustrative": true, "system": { "name": "International frontier-AI threshold response (Stubb-Støre Call, Sep 2026)", "version": "call-2026-illustrative", "activity": "limited_deployment", "environment": "Illustrative geopolitical composite: a scoped international threshold-response activity, not a lab product. Figures are teaching values, not a field measurement.", "allowed_actions": [ "Coordinate pre-deployment testing and independent evaluation when a named capability threshold is detected", "Share serious-incident reports among participating governments", "Explore convening an international standards and verification desk" ], "prohibited_actions": [ "Treat verbal support or a welcome as a signature", "Claim a unified international stop authority", "Greenwash a fragmented signature map as a solved regime" ] }, "stakes": { "severity": 4, "irreversibility": 4, "scale": 5, "autonomy": 4, "power_concentration": 4, "rights_affected": true, "rsi_relevant": true, "rationale": "A frontier capability jump with incomplete international correction can affect populations and rights at planetary scale. Independent review is required. Illustrative stakes, not a measured harm model." }, "critical_claims": [ { "id": "CL-CONVOKE", "claim": "The Call names a coordinated eval and incident-response path that can be assessed as one scoped activity.", "status": "supported", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-CALL" ] } ], "hazards": [ { "id": "HZ-THRESHOLD", "description": "A frontier capability threshold is crossed without coordinated evaluation or shared incident response taking effect.", "unacceptable": true, "irreversible": true, "controls_sufficient": "yes", "earliest_harm_seconds": 86400, "trigger_event": "A named capability threshold is detected and no coordinated eval desk is in effect", "rationale": "Illustrative only: this teaching record treats the Call's explore-an-institution language as a named control for a scoped reading. A real shared international breaker has not been demonstrated. Not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-CALL" ] } ], "timing": { "scenario": "A capability threshold is detected and a coordinated eval / incident response must take effect across participating governments.", "start_event": "The capability-threshold crossing becomes detectable under a documented international monitoring design.", "end_event": "Coordinated evaluation or incident response is confirmed in effect across the participating desk.", "l_components": { "detection": { "estimate": { "lower": 172800, "central": 345600, "upper": 432000 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative 2 to 5 days to detect a threshold crossing. Not a field measurement of any state's monitoring.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "decision": { "estimate": { "lower": 259200, "central": 432000, "upper": 604800 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative 3 to 7 days of diplomatic and desk decision delay. Not a field measurement.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "execution": { "estimate": { "lower": 172800, "central": 432000, "upper": 518400 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative 2 to 6 days to stand up coordinated eval or incident response. Not a field measurement of an international breaker.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] } }, "h": { "status": "known", "quantity": { "estimate": { "lower": 1814400, "central": 2592000, "upper": 3888000 }, "basis": "illustrative", "rationale": "Illustrative 21 to 45 days for how long shared eval evidence remains valid after a frontier capability jump. Deliberately wide. Not a field measurement. A stricter reading would record H as unknown.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-TIMING" ] }, "invalidation_events": [ "A new frontier capability jump that the last shared eval did not cover.", "A participating government withdraws from shared incident reporting.", "The explored verification institution is not stood up, or a parallel track splits the evidence." ] } }, "gears": { "governance": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "Signatures, verbal support, rejection, and a parallel intergovernmental track. No unified stop authority. Missing national republications are evidence gaps. Yellow, not red: a failed required control has not been shown. Greenwashed 'multilateral solved' claims are blocked while Governance is not green.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "equity": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "Eval capacity and incident-reporting burdens will not fall evenly across regions. The Call asks for access to scientific capacity; it does not yet show it. Illustrative yellow.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "aligned_incentives": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "Welcome and support without signature leave race incentives intact. A podium welcome is not a reversed incentive. Illustrative yellow.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "resilience": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "No shared international breaker has been proven. A stricter reading would record unknown and the advisory would become insufficient evidence. This teaching record rates yellow so the yellow-gear path can be shown. Not a field test.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] }, "steering": { "rating": "yellow", "rationale": "Threshold convening is still 'explore,' not an operating desk. Scope change, revocation and revalidation are not demonstrated across the international boundary.", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] } }, "breakers": [ { "id": "BR-CONVOKE", "required": true, "owner": "Illustrative international eval desk (teaching composite)", "trigger": "A named capability threshold is detected or a serious shared incident is reported.", "action": "Convene coordinated evaluation, confirm incident reporting is in effect, and record whether any participating government can halt the scoped activity.", "deadline_seconds": 1555200, "test_status": "passed", "tested_system_version": "call-2026-illustrative", "evidence_ids": [ "EV-GEARS" ] } ], "evidence": [ { "id": "EV-CALL", "title": "Official Call text and Finnish host narrative (illustrative reading)", "locator": "https://www.presidentti.fi/en/a-call-for-control-of-frontier-ai-models/", "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-23T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Teaching composite CALL-2026. The Call is a real document; the timing quantities and gear ratings are not field measurements." }, { "id": "EV-TIMING", "title": "Illustrative L and H worksheet for an international threshold response", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-23T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Deliberately wide planning bounds. Not a field measurement of L or H across states." }, { "id": "EV-GEARS", "title": "Illustrative gear reading of signature, support, rejection and parallel track", "locator": null, "source_kind": "illustrative", "captured_at": "2026-09-23T11:00:00Z", "validity_status": "current", "scope": "Geopolitical teaching reading. Not a legal finding." } ], "review": { "assessor": "Illustrative companion-site reader", "accountable_owner": "Illustrative international desk owner", "independent_reviewer": "Illustrative independent reviewer", "independent_status": "completed", "scope_matches": true, "valid_until": "2026-10-14T12:00:00Z", "dissent": [ "A stricter reading would record H unknown and Resilience unknown, which would make the advisory insufficient evidence rather than eligible with conditions." ], "limitations": [ "This is an illustrative geopolitical composite, not independently gathered evidence and not a legal finding." ] }, "actions": [ { "id": "AC-MAP", "description": "Publish a four-column map (sign / support / welcome / reject or parallel) and collect national republications, or mark them missing, before any green Governance claim.", "addresses": [ "gear:governance", "gear:aligned_incentives" ], "owner": "Illustrative international desk owner", "due_at": "2026-10-07T12:00:00Z", "verification_test": "The map is public and each listed country either republishes the Call or is marked missing.", "completed": false }, { "id": "AC-CAPACITY", "description": "Name eval-capacity gaps and tabletop a shared international breaker; do not treat this teaching pass as a proven control.", "addresses": [ "gear:equity", "gear:resilience" ], "owner": "Illustrative incident commander", "due_at": "2026-10-07T12:00:00Z", "verification_test": "A published list of eval-capacity gaps exists, and a named owner can halt the scoped activity without a new political meeting.", "completed": false }, { "id": "AC-STEER", "description": "Replace explore with an operating convening rule, and replace illustrative L and H with jointly measured quantities or record R as unknown.", "addresses": [ "gear:steering", "ratio:amber" ], "owner": "Illustrative international desk owner", "due_at": "2026-10-07T12:00:00Z", "verification_test": "A written If-Then convening card exists, and L and H have a basis other than illustrative or H is marked unknown.", "completed": false } ], "decision": { "advisory": "eligible_with_conditions", "reason_codes": [], "human": { "status": "awaiting_decision", "recorded_by": null, "recorded_at": null, "expires_at": null, "rationale": "Illustrative example; no permission to operate is granted." }, "ratio_snapshot": { "band": "amber", "lower": 0.15555555555555556, "central": 0.4666666666666667, "upper": 0.8571428571428571, "l_seconds": { "lower": 604800, "central": 1209600, "upper": 1555200 } } }, "reassessment": { "due_at": "2026-10-14T12:00:00Z", "triggers": [ "model_version", "tools_or_permissions", "environment", "critical_claim_change", "failed_control", "relevant_incident", "evidence_expiry" ] }, "limitations": [ "All figures and evidence are illustrative. This is a geopolitical teaching composite, not a field measurement, a legal finding, or a safety certification.", "A favorable or conditional advisory is not permission to operate and does not make Governance green." ] } ]